2.5 Carat Engagement Rings

• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Wide Band Cathedral Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,250

  Natalie's Price: $12,829

  You Save: 1,421 (10%)
  9 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Split Shank Pavé Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,690

  Natalie's Price: $10,529

  You Save: 1,161 (10%)
  3 Reviews
• Graduated Milgrain Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,500

  Natalie's Price: $10,359

  You Save: 1,141 (10%)
  
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Graduated Pavé Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,330

  Natalie's Price: $10,209

  You Save: 1,121 (10%)
  6 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Three Sided Pavé Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,720

  Natalie's Price: $10,549

  You Save: 1,171 (10%)
  3 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Three Sided Pavé Emerald Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,720

  Natalie's Price: $10,549

  You Save: 1,171 (10%)
  1 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Novo Pavé Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,500

  Natalie's Price: $10,359

  You Save: 1,141 (10%)
  2 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Novo Design Pavé Emerald Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,500

  Natalie's Price: $10,359

  You Save: 1,141 (10%)
  1 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Shared Prong Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,330

  Natalie's Price: $10,209

  You Save: 1,121 (10%)
  5 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Shared Prong Emerald Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,690

  Natalie's Price: $10,529

  You Save: 1,161 (10%)
  4 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Wide Band Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,720

  Natalie's Price: $10,549

  You Save: 1,171 (10%)
  2 Reviews
• French Cut Pavé Cushion Cut Diamond Halo Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,550

  Natalie's Price: $10,409

  You Save: 1,141 (10%)
  
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Shared Prong Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,330

  Natalie's Price: $10,209

  You Save: 1,121 (10%)
  2 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Shared Prong Princess Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $15,770

  Natalie's Price: $14,209

  You Save: 1,561 (10%)
  5 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  French Cut Pavé Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,110

  Natalie's Price: $10,009

  You Save: 1,101 (10%)
  5 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  French Cut Pavé Emerald Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,500

  Natalie's Price: $10,359

  You Save: 1,141 (10%)
  4 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Graduated Milgrain Emerald Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,500

  Natalie's Price: $10,359

  You Save: 1,141 (10%)
  1 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Twist Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,220

  Natalie's Price: $10,109

  You Save: 1,111 (10%)
  3 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Tapered Cathedral Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,200

  Natalie's Price: $10,089

  You Save: 1,111 (10%)
  5 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Cathedral Pave Set Emerald Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,200

  Natalie's Price: $10,089

  You Save: 1,111 (10%)
  2 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Cushion Cut Cross Prong Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,330

  Natalie's Price: $10,209

  You Save: 1,121 (10%)
  1 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Channel Set Cathedral Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,330

  Natalie's Price: $10,209

  You Save: 1,121 (10%)
  1 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Channel Set Cathedral Emerald Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,690

  Natalie's Price: $10,529

  You Save: 1,161 (10%)
  1 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Knife Edge Pavé Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,500

  Natalie's Price: $10,359

  You Save: 1,141 (10%)
  5 Reviews
• Cushion Outline Round Cut Diamond Halo Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,740

  Natalie's Price: $13,279

  You Save: 1,461 (10%)
  
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Knife Edge Pavé Emerald Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,500

  Natalie's Price: $10,359

  You Save: 1,141 (10%)
  1 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Channel Set Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,330

  Natalie's Price: $10,209

  You Save: 1,121 (10%)
  2 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Pavé Round Cut Diamond Halo Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,740

  Natalie's Price: $13,279

  You Save: 1,461 (10%)
  8 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Graduated Five Stone Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $12,210

  Natalie's Price: $10,999

  You Save: 1,211 (10%)
  8 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Graduated Five Stone Emerald Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $12,210

  Natalie's Price: $10,999

  You Save: 1,211 (10%)
  2 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Cushion Cut Diamond Halo Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,550

  Natalie's Price: $10,409

  You Save: 1,141 (10%)
  8 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Floating Halo Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,990

  Natalie's Price: $10,799

  You Save: 1,191 (10%)
  8 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Plain Shank Floating Halo Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $10,890

  Natalie's Price: $9,809

  You Save: 1,081 (10%)
  15 Reviews
• Pavé Halo Twisted Shank Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,740

  Natalie's Price: $13,279

  You Save: 1,461 (10%)
  
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Split Shank Cushion Cut Diamond Halo Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,990

  Natalie's Price: $10,799

  You Save: 1,191 (10%)
  6 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Floating Cushion Shape Halo Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $15,180

  Natalie's Price: $13,669

  You Save: 1,511 (10%)
  8 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Floating Round Halo Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $15,180

  Natalie's Price: $13,669

  You Save: 1,511 (10%)
  7 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Plain Shank Cushion Design Floating Halo Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,080

  Natalie's Price: $12,679

  You Save: 1,401 (10%)
  7 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Plain Shank Floating Halo Round Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,080

  Natalie's Price: $12,679

  You Save: 1,401 (10%)
  7 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Royal Split Shank Cushion Design Halo Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $15,180

  Natalie's Price: $13,669

  You Save: 1,511 (10%)
  4 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Royal Split Shank Round Cut Diamond Halo Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $15,180

  Natalie's Price: $13,669

  You Save: 1,511 (10%)
  5 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Cushion Outline French Cut Pavé Halo Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,740

  Natalie's Price: $13,279

  You Save: 1,461 (10%)
  4 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Round Outline French Cut Pavé Halo Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,740

  Natalie's Price: $13,279

  You Save: 1,461 (10%)
  4 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Two-sided Micro Pavé Halo Round Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,410

  Natalie's Price: $12,979

  You Save: 1,431 (10%)
  4 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Two-sided Micro Pavé Cathedral Halo Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $15,180

  Natalie's Price: $13,669

  You Save: 1,511 (10%)
  6 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Trio Micro Pavé Round Cut Halo Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $15,730

  Natalie's Price: $14,169

  You Save: 1,561 (10%)
  4 Reviews
• Trellis Trilogy 3 Stone Pavé Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $15,400

  Natalie's Price: $13,869

  You Save: 1,531 (10%)
  
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Classic Shank Two-sided Micro Pavé Diamond Halo Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,410

  Natalie's Price: $12,979

  You Save: 1,431 (10%)
  4 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Trellis 3 Stone Round Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $15,180

  Natalie's Price: $13,669

  You Save: 1,511 (10%)
  9 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  3 Stone Past Present Future Trilogy Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $15,400

  Natalie's Price: $13,869

  You Save: 1,531 (10%)
  8 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  3 Stone Trilogy Past Present Future Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $15,510

  Natalie's Price: $13,969

  You Save: 1,541 (10%)
  5 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Wide Band Pavé Round Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,910

  Natalie's Price: $13,429

  You Save: 1,481 (10%)
  8 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  3 Stone Channel Set Round Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,910

  Natalie's Price: $13,429

  You Save: 1,481 (10%)
  3 Reviews
• 
  

  Tapered Cathedral Solitaire Engagement Ring & Wedding Band Bridal Set

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,850

  Natalie's Price: $13,379

  You Save: 1,471 (10%)
  1 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Cushion Cut Split Shank Micropavé Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,690

  Natalie's Price: $10,529

  You Save: 1,161 (10%)
  1 Reviews
• Trilogy 3 Stone Past Present Future Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $15,240

  Natalie's Price: $13,719

  You Save: 1,521 (10%)