2.5 Carat Engagement Rings

• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Cross Prong Design Round Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,520

  Natalie's Price: $9,449

  You Save: 5,071 (35%)
  11 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Graduated Side Stone Round Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,520

  Natalie's Price: $9,449

  You Save: 5,071 (35%)
  11 Reviews
• French Cut Pavé Round Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,300

  Natalie's Price: $9,309

  You Save: 4,991 (35%)
  
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Sidestones Cathedral Design Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,520

  Natalie's Price: $9,449

  You Save: 5,071 (35%)
  10 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Shared Prong Round Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,520

  Natalie's Price: $9,449

  You Save: 5,071 (35%)
  11 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Tapered Cathedral Round Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,390

  Natalie's Price: $9,359

  You Save: 5,031 (35%)
  14 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Graduated Pavé Round Brilliant Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,520

  Natalie's Price: $9,449

  You Save: 5,071 (35%)
  9 Reviews
• Infinity Design Round Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,940

  Natalie's Price: $9,719

  You Save: 5,221 (35%)
  
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Graduated Side Stone Emerald Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,660

  Natalie's Price: $7,589

  You Save: 4,071 (35%)
  3 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Twist Round Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,410

  Natalie's Price: $9,379

  You Save: 5,031 (35%)
  8 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Six Prong Solstice Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,520

  Natalie's Price: $9,449

  You Save: 5,071 (35%)
  4 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Knife Edge Pavé Round Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,690

  Natalie's Price: $9,559

  You Save: 5,131 (35%)
  5 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Graduated Milgrain Round Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,690

  Natalie's Price: $9,559

  You Save: 5,131 (35%)
  9 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Rounded Cathedral Round Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $13,990

  Natalie's Price: $9,109

  You Save: 4,881 (35%)
  10 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Rounded Cathedral Emerald Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $10,800

  Natalie's Price: $7,029

  You Save: 3,771 (35%)
  1 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Six Prong Round Brilliant Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $13,970

  Natalie's Price: $9,089

  You Save: 4,881 (35%)
  20 Reviews
• Split Shank Round Cut Pavé Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,880

  Natalie's Price: $9,679

  You Save: 5,201 (35%)
  
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Novo Emerald Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $10,950

  Natalie's Price: $7,119

  You Save: 3,831 (35%)
  1 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Novo Round Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,140

  Natalie's Price: $9,199

  You Save: 4,941 (35%)
  13 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Tapered Cathedral Emerald Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $10,750

  Natalie's Price: $6,999

  You Save: 3,751 (35%)
  2 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Three Sided Pavé Round Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,910

  Natalie's Price: $9,699

  You Save: 5,211 (35%)
  4 Reviews
• Graduated Side Stone Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,330

  Natalie's Price: $7,379

  You Save: 3,951 (35%)
  
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Micro Pavé Round Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $15,400

  Natalie's Price: $10,019

  You Save: 5,381 (35%)
  6 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Round Cut Channel Set Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,520

  Natalie's Price: $9,449

  You Save: 5,071 (35%)
  2 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Shared Prong Round Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,520

  Natalie's Price: $9,449

  You Save: 5,071 (35%)
  3 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Infinity Design Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,750

  Natalie's Price: $7,649

  You Save: 4,101 (35%)
  4 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Tapered Cathedral Cushion Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $10,750

  Natalie's Price: $6,999

  You Save: 3,751 (35%)
  5 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Novo Cushion Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $10,950

  Natalie's Price: $7,119

  You Save: 3,831 (35%)
  3 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Cross Prong Cushion Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $10,780

  Natalie's Price: $7,019

  You Save: 3,761 (35%)
  6 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Classic Cushion Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $10,870

  Natalie's Price: $7,069

  You Save: 3,801 (35%)
  15 Reviews
• Novo Design Round Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,690

  Natalie's Price: $9,559

  You Save: 5,131 (35%)
  
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Knife Edge Cushion Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $10,670

  Natalie's Price: $6,949

  You Save: 3,721 (35%)
  4 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Split Shank Cushion Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $10,890

  Natalie's Price: $7,089

  You Save: 3,801 (35%)
  3 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Flat Edged Cathedral Cushion Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,060

  Natalie's Price: $7,199

  You Save: 3,861 (35%)
  3 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Hand Engraved Milgrain Cushion Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $10,950

  Natalie's Price: $7,119

  You Save: 3,831 (35%)
  3 Reviews
• Tapered Cathedral Round Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $13,940

  Natalie's Price: $9,069

  You Save: 4,871 (35%)
  
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Hand Engraved Vintage Cushion Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $10,840

  Natalie's Price: $7,049

  You Save: 3,791 (35%)
  4 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Lucida Wide Band Cushion Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,090

  Natalie's Price: $7,219

  You Save: 3,871 (35%)
  8 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Flat Edged Cathedral Cushion Cut Solitaire Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $10,730

  Natalie's Price: $6,979

  You Save: 3,751 (35%)
  5 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Petal Design Cushion Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $10,810

  Natalie's Price: $7,039

  You Save: 3,771 (35%)
  4 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Split Shank Cushion Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $10,840

  Natalie's Price: $7,049

  You Save: 3,791 (35%)
  3 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Cross Prong Round Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $13,970

  Natalie's Price: $9,089

  You Save: 4,881 (35%)
  9 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Crown Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,140

  Natalie's Price: $9,199

  You Save: 4,941 (35%)
  7 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Classic Four Prong Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,060

  Natalie's Price: $9,149

  You Save: 4,911 (35%)
  13 Reviews
• Infinity Design Emerald Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,750

  Natalie's Price: $7,649

  You Save: 4,101 (35%)
  
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Split Shank Round Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,080

  Natalie's Price: $9,159

  You Save: 4,921 (35%)
  6 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Hand Engraved Milgrain Round Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,140

  Natalie's Price: $9,199

  You Save: 4,941 (35%)
  4 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Hand Engraved Round Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,030

  Natalie's Price: $9,129

  You Save: 4,901 (35%)
  4 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Hand Engraved Vintage Style Emerald Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $10,840

  Natalie's Price: $7,049

  You Save: 3,791 (35%)
  1 Reviews
• Rounded Cathedral Cushion Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $10,800

  Natalie's Price: $7,029

  You Save: 3,771 (35%)
  
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Knife Edge Round Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $13,860

  Natalie's Price: $9,019

  You Save: 4,841 (35%)
  9 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Flat Edged Cathedral Round Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,250

  Natalie's Price: $9,269

  You Save: 4,981 (35%)
  3 Reviews
• 
  White Gold Yellow Gold Rose Gold

  Wide Band Cathedral Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $14,250

  Natalie's Price: $9,269

  You Save: 4,981 (35%)
  8 Reviews
• Wide Band Cushion Cut Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

  Starting at

  Retail Price: $11,060

  Natalie's Price: $7,199

  You Save: 3,861 (35%)